How to Stop Buying the
Wrong 


Shade

Foundation

Makeup should not feel like gambling.

If you’ve ever bought a foundation that looked perfect in the store… then looked orange, gray, too pink, too dark, too light, or just off once you got home — you are not doing anything wrong.

Foundation is tricky because it’s not just about “light” or “medium.” It’s about undertone, depth, lighting, formula, and how your skin actually behaves in real life.

This guide will help you choose shades more confidently — and stop wasting money on almost-right products.

Why foundation matching feels so hard (and it’s not your fault)

A few very normal reasons foundation goes sideways:

  • Store lighting lies (it’s almost always warmer or harsher than real life)
  • Your face and neck are different depths (especially with sun, redness, or pigmentation)
  • Undertone is misunderstood (warm/cool/neutral doesn’t tell the full story)
  • Your skin changes seasonally, hormonally, and with age
  • Formula can change the color once it dries down (oxidation is real)

The goal isn’t “perfect” - it’s believable and wearable

Your best foundation match is the one that:

  • looks natural in daylight
  • blends seamlessly into your overall coloring
  • doesn’t fight your neck/chest
  • makes your skin look like skin
  • stays true as it wears (no weird color shift)

Here’s the truth: your face is almost never the same color as your body.
Between redness, sun, hormones, skincare, and just… being a human, your face can change constantly.

So instead of matching foundation to the “problem areas” on your face, I like to match it to the part of your body you actually love the coloring of — usually your chest, sometimes your neck, or even your arms.

Then we use placement and balance to make the face look fresh and even — without trying to “paint over” your natural skin.

Match to Your Body (Not Your Face)

If you have redness in the face, matching to the red will always pull you off.
The goal is to balance the redness, not turn it into your undertone.

A quick note on redness:

And about “one-and-done” foundation…

Most people want one perfect forever shade. I get it.
But in real life, that’s rare.

Makeup artists mix shades (and even use primary color adjusters) all the time — and you’re probably not trying to do all that.

So here’s the practical goal: wear what makes you feel your best and get as close as you can with the whole picture and the whole picture is connecting your head and face, to your body.

The 3-Step Foundation Match Method

Step 3: Let It Set, Then Step Into Natural Light

Give the foundation 5–10 minutes to settle.
Many formulas shift as they dry.

Then check it in natural light.
The right shade doesn’t stand out — it quietly disappears into your body.

Step 2: Test More Than One Shade

Always test 2–3 shades side by side.
A single swatch can be misleading, especially with undertones.

Seeing them together makes it obvious which one blends into your natural coloring — and which ones are too warm, cool, light, or heavy.

Step 1: Match to Your Body, Not Your Face

Skip the back of your hand — and skip matching directly to the face.
Faces almost always carry redness or uneven tone.

Instead, compare shades against your chest and arms — the coloring you actually want your face to relate to.

© 2024-2025 Heather Maria Beauty | beauty@heathermaria.org  |   Privacy Policy & Disclaimer  |  Website Photo Credits

back to top

I have made a personal commitment to use #donoharmbeauty to effect change in the world. 

All of the makeup I use is cruelty-free. Always.

Not only do I meticulously research and choose furry-friend friendly products for your beauty experience, but I also give back a portion of my profits to an animal charity that protects animals from cruelty, exploitation, and other abuses. I choose to do this for all the living creatures who don't get a choice.

I have made a personal commitment to use #donoharmbeauty to effect change in the world. 

I love animals, and I think it’s an atrocity that 500,000 animals are harmed and killed each year for the sake of cosmetics testing. This does not have to happen. 

That’s why all of the makeup I use is cruelty-free. Always.

All of the makeup I use is cruelty-free. Always.

Not only do I meticulously research and choose furry-friend friendly products for your beauty experience, but I also give back a portion of my profits to an animal charity that protects animals from cruelty, exploitation, and other abuses. I choose to do this for all the living creatures who don't get a choice.

close

Because kindness starts with choices, even mascara choices.

-Heather

For the Love of Animals